If college is in your child’s future, what should you choose: the SAT or the ACT? Here are the facts, pros, and cons of the SAT vs. the ACT!
The SAT or ACT? Well, twenty years ago, making the choice was easy as pie. Back then, it all boiled down to where you wanted to go to college: you sat the ACT for colleges in the North and Midwest, and the SAT for the rest of them (colleges in the South, and on both the East and West Coasts).
Nowadays, basically every university in the United States accepts both SAT and ACT results. Even if a school prefers one over the other, admissions officers usually convert the scores interchangeably.
Why Are These Tests Needed?
We need these standardized tests so that we can compare the abilities of students across the country—fairly. For example, a 4.0 GPA at one school can mean something entirely different to a 4.0 earned at another school. How else can we make up for obvious differences between student knowledge, teaching aptitude, degree of difficulty across different curriculums, and just plain old marking biases?
That’s where standardized tests like the SAT and ACT come in, as they help compensate for these differences by leveling the playing field. Interestingly, a student’s scores also help predict what kind of academic success they’ll have in their first year in college.
The SAT and the ACT
The creators of both the SAT and ACT were guided by very similar philosophies: to design an instrument to assess a student’s critical thinking and problem-solving skills. The similarities go much deeper.
In both tests, students will find questions that are objective and have only one correct answer. Sections dedicated to math, vocabulary, and reading comprehension assess the learners’ “innate abilities.” Tricky and confusing phrasing is purposely used to determine skill level.
This also has the effect of checking how a student performs under pressure and their ability to identify exactly what is being asked of them. It isn’t necessarily measuring comprehension on a specific subject, but of course does cover basic high school material. What the examiners are more interested in is how well a student can critically think through a problem—considering they are given roughly one minute per question—and then move on.
Now that the SAT has been redesigned, the format is very similar to the ACT. When the new president of the College Board was appointed, he hired ACT writers to create the redesigned SAT. The resemblance between the instruments is good news to any college hopeful. Both have four long sections, require a student to understand basic test-taking techniques, and need them to answer the questions quickly. The best score a student can receive on the SAT is 1600 and 36 on the ACT.
|Reading||Four answer choices||Five answer choices|
|Writing||Grammar, style, and analysis||Grammar, style, and analysis|
|Math||Trigonometry, Geometry, Algebra;|
contains geometry formulas
|Trigonometry, geometry analysis, no grid-in questions|
|Science||No Science section||Science questions similar to the SAT reading section|
|Essay||Analytical response required; duration 50 minutes||Persuasive writing required; duration 40 minutes|
|Scores||Scores are not averaged||Sections are averaged|
|Annual Frequency||Offered seven times per year||Offered six times per year|
|Permitted Attempts||Unlimited||Limited to twelve attempts|
|Best Possible Score||1600||36|
What is crystal clear is that learning critical thinking skills will benefit students whether they sit either or both tests. And there are plenty of other standardized exams where these skills are completely transferable. These include the popular PSAT/NMSQT test, which when taken in a student’s junior year could yield incredible scholarships like full tuition, free room and board, graduate school money, study abroad stipends, and more. The list of other exams that will benefit from learning test-taking skills include AP, Subject Tests, GRE, CLEP, LSAT, ISEE, and so on.
When you boil it down, the SAT and ACT largely examine the same aspects of a student’s capabilities, in similar ways, yielding similar results that can be converted to suit the institution you or your student is applying for. The question I find people are asking now is this: “if they are so similar, is there a benefit in taking both tests?” The answer is “yes.”
Despite the incredible similarities, it does seem prudent to consider doing just that. Whereas both tests fulfill the same role in the admissions process of college, some colleges do give a better scholarship based on their preference for using the results of one test over the other. Nowadays, many students are considering taking both the SAT and ACT so they can stack the cards in their favor, showcase their abilities, and receive more money.
If you’re looking for a program that will help you or your student ace the SAT (and other standardized tests that could make a huge difference to your future) then take the time to check out the College Prep Genius programs. Thousands of students swear by Jean Burk’s system and you will too!